The Historical Society of Avon ParkAVON PARK, FL · EST. 1886
Menu
Admin Sign-In

Catfish Lake Seminoles ranged northward and westward with no documented camps, cow pens, or trails toward Lake Istokpoga

Ethnographic surveys, military reconnaissance, and systematic archaeological inventories document the seasonal mobility, domestic economy, and territorial range of the Catfish Lake Seminole band during the late nineteenth century.[maccauley-1887][stone-chipco][austin-1987-survey] While local traditions frequently assume that Seminole hunters and drovers moved freely south across the modern Highlands County line to establish camps or cattle pens around Lake Istokpoga, historical and archaeological records show that the band’s documented movements ran northward, westward, and selectively southward to Lake Okeechobee, leaving no documented domestic or pastoral presence in the interior of Highlands County.[maccauley-1887][austin-1987-survey]

The Catfish Lake settlement and its northern mobility

In October 1880, the Reverend Clay MacCauley conducted the first systematic post-war census of the Florida Seminoles for the Smithsonian Institution’s Bureau of Ethnology and the United States Census Office.[maccauley-1887] MacCauley identified twenty-eight individuals residing in two permanent camps at the “Cat Fish Lake settlement,” situated on a small lake between Lake Pierce and Lake Rosalie in eastern Polk County, towards the headwaters of the Kissimmee River.[maccauley-1887] The settlement was led by the elderly Muscogee-speaking chief Echo Emathla Chopco (Chipco) and his principal lieutenant and successor, Täl-la-häs-ke (Tallahassee).[maccauley-1887][stone-chipco][seminole-tourism-chipco]

When MacCauley visited the band in midwinter 1880–1881, twenty-two members of the Catfish Lake community were not at their home village.[maccauley-1887] They had moved twenty miles northward to a temporary encampment at a wild koonti (Zamia pumila) ground on Horse Creek, near the abandoned Second Seminole War site of Fort Davenport in northeastern Polk County.[maccauley-1887] A woman in the camp informed MacCauley that animals had destroyed their sweet potato crop at Catfish Lake, forcing the families to harvest and process wild starch roots to avert winter hunger.[maccauley-1887]

At Horse Creek, Täl-la-häs-ke and his family constructed temporary palmetto-thatch wall-tent lodges and single-roofed sheds with elevated storage platforms.[maccauley-1887] MacCauley also documented the northward mobility of individual band members, noting that Me-le, a mixed-race member of the Catfish Lake band, traveled seventy miles north to Orlando to purchase manufactured footwear and view town life.[maccauley-1887]

Livestock economy: horses, swine, and the absence of cow pens

The economic activities of the Catfish Lake band centered on subsistence farming, horse ownership, swine, and trade hunting, rather than cattle ranching.[maccauley-1887][seminole-tourism-chipco] MacCauley observed that an “unusual interest in horses” had developed at Catfish Lake, recording twenty horses owned by the twenty-eight residents—representing approximately half of the estimated thirty-five to forty horses owned by Seminoles throughout the entire state of Florida.[maccauley-1887] The band also maintained extensive herds of swine and flocks of chickens, and cultivated twenty acres of corn, sweet potatoes, and sugar cane in fertile hammock land near Lake Pierce.[maccauley-1887][stone-chipco]

In contrast to the horse herd, cattle were scarce.[maccauley-1887] MacCauley reported that approximately fifty cattle were owned by Florida Seminoles statewide, primarily in the southern settlements around the Big Cypress Swamp and Fisheating Creek.[maccauley-1887] Neither MacCauley in 1880 nor Lieutenant Richard Henry Pratt, who inspected Chipco’s village in 1879 for the Office of Indian Affairs, documented any dedicated cow pens, cattle pastures, or open-range herds maintained by the Catfish Lake people south of the Polk County line.[maccauley-1887][seminole-tourism-chipco] While pioneer white cattlemen operated stock pens in the Kissimmee River valley (such as the Smith Grade cow pens in Township 32 South), these were built and used by pioneer settlers and timber operators, not by Seminoles.[austin-1987-survey]

Overland trade corridors to the west

Rather than traveling south into the interior of what became Highlands County, the Catfish Lake Seminoles maintained active commercial ties to white trade centers to the west.[stone-chipco][seminole-tourism-chipco] Throughout the 1870s and 1880s, Chipco and Tallahassee regularly led parties to Tampa, Fort Meade, and Fort Dade to barter deer hides, otter pelts, egret plumes, jerked venison, wild honey, and beadwork for commercial staples including dry goods, gunpowder, lead shot, salt, coffee, and steel otter traps.[maccauley-1887][stone-chipco][seminole-tourism-chipco]

These journeys followed established east-west overland trails across the Peace River valley in Polk County, bypassing the scrub and sandy pine ridges of Highlands County.[stone-chipco]

Ceremonial travel southward and the archaeological record

The only documented southward travel by members of the Catfish Lake settlement was political and ceremonial.[maccauley-1887] Chipco identified his people as “Tallahassee Indians” and maintained a high degree of civil autonomy from the southern Mikasuki-speaking bands at Fish Eating Creek, Big Cypress, and the Miami River.[maccauley-1887] Because the northern bands did not perform the annual Green Corn Dance, Catfish Lake families journeyed south to the tribal ceremonial center on Fisheating Creek in modern Glades County when they chose to participate in the festival or attend council with head chief Tûs-ta-nûg-ge and medicine man Hŏs-pa-ta-ki.[maccauley-1887]

This ceremonial corridor followed the Kissimmee River floodplain and the western margin of Lake Okeechobee, rather than crossing the interior Lake Wales Ridge or the Lake Istokpoga basin.[maccauley-1887] MacCauley noted the topographic limit of the central ridge, observing that the “range of barren sand hills which extends from the north along the middle of Florida to the headwaters of the Kissimmee River ends at Cat Fish Lake.”[maccauley-1887]

Systematic archaeological surveys across the 106,210 acres of the Avon Park Air Force Range—occupying the intermediate territory between Lake Pierce and Lake Istokpoga across eastern Polk and eastern Highlands counties—corroborate this historical absence.[austin-1987-survey] Intensive pedestrian and subsurface testing recorded extensive pre-Columbian Belle Glade and Archaic sites, as well as 1850 military posts (Fort Arbuckle and Fort Kissimmee) and late nineteenth-century homesteads, but failed to identify a single historic Seminole village, hunting camp, trail, or cattle pen.[austin-1987-survey]

Following Chipco’s death at Lake Pierce in October 1881 and the abandonment of the village around 1890 under pressure from expanding white settlement, Tallahassee and the surviving band members moved eastward and southward toward the Cow Creek and Fort Pierce communities, confirming that the Lake Istokpoga country never served as a residential or pastoral base for the Catfish Lake band.[stone-chipco][seminole-tourism-chipco]

References

Where this comes from

Evidence
corroborated — More than one independent source agrees.
Review
unverified — Drafted from sources but not yet checked by a volunteer.
Rights
society

Sources

  1. Clay MacCauley, The Seminole Indians of Florida (Fifth Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology, 1883-'84) (1887) · official
  2. Spessard Stone, Chipco: Tallahassee Chief (2026) · secondary
  3. Florida Seminole Tourism, Spotlight on History: The Life of Chief Chipco (2026) · secondary
  4. Robert J. Austin, Prehistoric and Early Historic Settlement in the Kissimmee River Valley: An Archaeological Survey of the Avon Park Air Force Base (1987) · official

Something here wrong, or incomplete? The Society would rather know. Tell a volunteer.

Have a question about this record?

← Back to collection

Ask A.P.

Ask the archive

    Try asking:

    0 / 500

    A.P. answers only from the Society's own archive and cites what it used. Questions are not linked to you; search history is stored on your device only (how it works).Ask a volunteer for anything it cannot answer.