The Historical Society of Avon ParkAVON PARK, FL · EST. 1886
Menu
Admin Sign-In

This is a draft. It is published so it can be read and corrected, not because it is finished.

Seminole Occupation and the Seminole Wars in What Became Highlands County

Summary

The honest answer to “were the Seminole here?” is: this was Seminole country, but no Seminole town or camp is documented on the ground that became Highlands County. The evidence is regional, and a museum should say so rather than invent a local story. Avon Park and Sebring themselves are settler names of the 1880s and 1910s, with no Indigenous derivation.

What is documented is substantial. In April 1843 the United States Army described the temporary reservation left to the surviving Seminole as lying “west and south of Lake Istokopa” — Lake Istokpoga, in Highlands County — which puts the boundary of Seminole country directly against a Highlands County lake.[stone-chipco] Linguistic analysis by William A. Read confirms the lake’s name as authentic Muscogee (Creek)—isti (person) + ok (water) + poka/poga (perished or killed), signifying “people perished in the water.”[read-1934] Fort Kissimmee, about twenty miles east of Avon Park, was built inside the modern county in 1850.[wiki-fort-arbuckle] Sixty Seminole people were forced aboard a steamer at Fort Arbuckle, on the county’s northern edge, in February 1850 and deported to New Orleans.[wiki-fort-arbuckle] And the country immediately south, along Fisheating Creek, held four Seminole camps with thirty-two individuals in 1880, part of a statewide count of thirty-seven families.[maccauley-1887]

The chronology and the forts are well documented; the standard scholarly account of the period is John K. Mahon’s history of the Second Seminole War, and several local place-name and county-line questions remain unresolved.[mahon-second-war]

Who the Seminole are, and are not

The Seminole formed in the eighteenth century, largely from Lower Creek and Upper Creek migrants moving south out of Georgia and Alabama into a Florida whose original peoples — the Mayaca, the Jororo, the Calusa — had already been destroyed by disease and slave raiding. They are not descendants of those peoples. Local histories that move straight from “the Indians” to “the Seminoles” skip a whole population and the manner of its destruction.

The Seminole Tribe of Florida and the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida are living nations with their own governments, their own historians, and their own museum — the Ah-Tah-Thi-Ki Museum on the Big Cypress reservation, which exists to hold and present this history as Seminole people tell it.[ahtahthiki] It should be consulted before any of this material is interpreted publicly. Nothing in this report should be written in the past tense.

Seminole country in the Kissimmee and Peace valleys

The interior between the Peace and the Kissimmee was Seminole country through the first half of the nineteenth century, and it remained the refuge of those who evaded removal afterwards.

The best-documented local leader is Chipco (Echo Emathla Chopco), a Muscogee-speaking Red Stick Upper Creek chief born in Alabama around 1800 to 1805, who fled to Florida after the Battle of Horseshoe Bend in 1814 and settled in the Peace River country near present Bartow. He fought at the Dade engagement in December 1835, evaded deportation through both later wars, and died near Lake Pierce on 16 October 1881.[stone-chipco] Every one of his documented villages — Thonotosassa, near Fort Gardiner, Lake Hamilton, Lake Marion, Lake Hatchineha, Lake Pierce — is in what is now Polk County.[stone-chipco][hmdb-chipco] None is in Highlands County, and none should be claimed as such.

Chipco’s band traded hides, furs, bird plumes, jerked venison and beadwork at Tampa into the 1880s, a generation after the wars ended.[stone-chipco] An 1847 army officer’s description of Seminole subsistence in this period records deerskins for clothing and trade, corn, pumpkins, potatoes, beans and peas grown, and venison, turkey, fish and oysters taken.[stone-chipco]

South of the county, Fisheating Creek carries a documented Seminole name — Thlothlopopka-Hatchee, “the river where fish are eaten” — recorded on an 1839 military map.[fisheating-outpost] The Creek-speaking community that regrouped in that country after the wars is ancestral to today’s Brighton Reservation, and its range took in the Kissimmee valley and the country north and west of Lake Okeechobee.

Cattle

This matters more to Highlands County than it might appear, because the county’s later identity as ranching country has a Seminole root.

Seminole cattle ownership predates removal by generations. The Tribe’s own historic preservation office traces it to cattle taken from Spanish herds, and names Ahaya — Cowkeeper — chief of the Alachua band, as building a herd reported at seven to ten thousand head on Paynes Prairie by 1775.[thpo-cowkeeper] That herd was in north-central Florida, well outside this area, but it establishes the tradition as Seminole and old rather than something introduced later.

Most of it was destroyed by the removal wars. Small-scale ranching survived in the Big Cypress and Lake Okeechobee country, and a formal program restarted at Brighton in the 1930s, where five Seminole men — Frank Shore, Charlie Micco, Naha Tiger, Willie Gopher and Willie Tiger — worked with a federal agent, Fred Montsdeoca, to build a modern operation.[thpo-cowkeeper][fl-seminole-tourism] By 1946 the Brighton range carried around 2,700 head.[fl-seminole-tourism]

The starter herd was federal drought-relief cattle shipped by rail from Arizona in 1936; see the Brighton starter cattle herd.

The wars in this country

The Second Seminole War, 1835 to 1842, was fought over forced removal and was the longest and costliest of the three. Its decisive engagement in this region was the Battle of Lake Okeechobee on Christmas Day 1837, fought in what is now Okeechobee County, about forty-five miles east-southeast of Avon Park. Roughly a thousand United States troops under Zachary Taylor fought something between 380 and 480 Seminole and allied fighters under Abiaka (Sam Jones), Alligator, Billy Bowlegs and Coacoochee. The army lost 26 dead and 112 wounded against 11 Seminole dead and 14 wounded, and Taylor withdrew afterwards.[wiki-lake-okeechobee-battle]

Taylor’s march to that battle ran down the Kissimmee, along the eastern edge of what became Highlands County. He built Fort Gardiner on the Kissimmee on 2 December 1837, marched south from it on 19 December with 1,032 soldiers, and on 21 December built Fort Basinger further down the river as a supply and holding post.[wiki-fort-gardiner]

A second chain of posts went up in 1849 and 1850 across this interior, running from the Manatee River to the Indian River: Fort Chokonikla, Fort Meade, Fort Clinch, Fort Arbuckle, Fort Kissimmee. Of these, only Fort Kissimmee is confirmed inside modern Highlands County. It was built in January 1850, was badly affected by malaria, was reactivated for the Third Seminole War, and closed in 1858. Nothing survives but the cemetery.

Fort Arbuckle, built the same year on the northeast shore of Lake Arbuckle, sits inside the Avon Park Air Force Range, which spans Polk and Highlands counties; the one geolocation found places it in Polk County near Frostproof, and its exact site is unverified.[wiki-fort-arbuckle] Lake Arbuckle and Arbuckle Creek are not Seminole names; both take their name from this 1850 army post, itself named for Brigadier General Matthew Arbuckle.[wiki-fort-arbuckle] Fort Basinger sits close to the Highlands–Okeechobee line and sources disagree about which side.

Removal

Two forced deportations are documented from posts on this county’s edge, and both should be described as what they were.

In February 1850, about sixty Seminole men, women and children were assembled at Fort Arbuckle and put aboard the steamer Fashion for shipment to New Orleans, shortly before the fort was abandoned.[wiki-fort-arbuckle]

At the close of the Third Seminole War in 1858, Billy Bowlegs’s band — reported as 33 to 38 fighting men and 80 to 85 women and children — boarded the steamer Grey Cloud at Fort Myers on 4 May, and the Quapaw carried deportees up the Mississippi and Arkansas rivers to Fort Smith, arriving 28 May, for onward removal to Indian Territory.[fcit-bowlegs] Bowlegs was paid $6,500 with further sums to subchiefs and individuals. That payment does not make the removal voluntary. The alternative offered was continued war against a population reduced to a few hundred people.

The war was declared over on 8 May 1858. A number of Seminole people refused to go and stayed. The government put the figure at about a hundred, and revised it upward when two further bands totalling seventy-five people were recruited for removal in December 1858 and shipped west on 15 February 1859; the Florida Department of State gives roughly two to three hundred remaining in the state.[wiki-seminole-wars][dos-seminole-history] The larger figure of fewer than a thousand that appears in the Tribe’s own history belongs to an earlier date — the end of the Second Seminole War in 1842, and the start of the third in 1855 — and not to the aftermath of 1858; see the post-1858 population figures.

After the wars

Those who stayed withdrew into the Everglades and the Big Cypress, and into the country north of Lake Okeechobee, and built an economy around trade — alligator hides, deer skins, and bird plumage moving to northern markets through trading posts, one of which east of Lake Okeechobee grew into the town of Indiantown.[thpo-seminole-history]

Drainage broke that. In the Tribe’s own words, the canals meant “not only losing the canoe routes they relied on for transportation, but their isolation as canals and roads cut through their lands.”[thpo-seminole-history] Along Fisheating Creek, the 1880 federal census by Clay MacCauley recorded four Seminole camps with thirty-two individuals, resolving a later commercial conflation that misapplied MacCauley’s statewide count of thirty-seven families to Fisheating Creek alone.[maccauley-1887][fisheating-outpost] By 1930 sugar cane, cattle ranching, and drainage operations had forced the remaining families out.[fisheating-outpost]

By 1938 three reservations totalling over 80,000 acres had been established, near Dania, Big Cypress, and Brighton.[thpo-seminole-history] The Seminole Tribe of Florida organized itself under a constitution in 1957, meeting through that decade under an oak on the Hollywood reservation in response to federal termination policy, and established a two-tiered government of a Tribal Council and a Board of Directors.[stof-council-oak] The Miccosukee Tribe, descended from Mikasuki-speaking people who never surrendered, was separately recognized when its constitution was approved on 11 January 1962.[miccosukee-history]

References

Where this comes from

Evidence
single-source — One source. Treat as reported, not established.
Review
unverified — Drafted from sources but not yet checked by a volunteer.
Rights
society

Sources

  1. William A. Read (Louisiana State University Press, 1934), Florida Place-Names of Indian Origin and Seminole Personal Names (1934)
  2. Spessard Stone, Chipco: Tallahassee Chief (2026)
  3. Seminole Tribe of Florida, Tribal Historic Preservation Office, Seminole History (2026)
  4. Seminole Tribe of Florida, The Council Oak (2026)
  5. Seminole Tribe of Florida, Tribal Historic Preservation Office, Cowkeeper's Legacy: A Seminole Story (2026)
  6. Wikipedia, Fort Arbuckle (Florida) (2026)
  7. Wikipedia, Fort Gardiner (2026)
  8. Wikipedia, Battle of Lake Okeechobee (2026)
  9. Florida Center for Instructional Technology, University of South Florida, Exploring Florida Documents: Billy Bowlegs and the Seminole War (2026)
  10. Wikipedia, Seminole Wars (2026) · secondary
  11. Florida Department of State, Seminole History (2026) · official
  12. The Historical Marker Database, Chief Chipco historical marker, Winter Haven, Polk County (2026)
  13. Fisheating Creek Outpost, Camp History (Fisheating Creek) (2026)
  14. Clay MacCauley, The Seminole Indians of Florida (Fifth Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology, 1883-'84) (1887) · official
  15. Florida Seminole Tourism, Red Barn and Seminole Cattle; Spotlight on the Brighton Seminole Reservation (2026)
  16. Seminole Tribe of Florida, Ah-Tah-Thi-Ki Museum (2026)
  17. Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida, Miccosukee Tribe history (2026)
  18. John K. Mahon, History of the Second Seminole War, 1835-1842 - identified as the standard authority; not read (1967)

Something here wrong, or incomplete? The Society would rather know. Tell a volunteer.

Have a question about this record?

← Back to collection

Ask A.P.

Ask the archive

    Try asking:

    0 / 500

    A.P. answers only from the Society's own archive and cites what it used. Questions are not linked to you; search history is stored on your device only (how it works).Ask a volunteer for anything it cannot answer.