The Historical Society of Avon ParkAVON PARK, FL · EST. 1886
Menu
Admin Sign-In

Seminole trade, census, and administrative geography documents no presence in Highlands County (1870-1942)

In the decades between the end of the Third Seminole War and the onset of World War II, the surviving Florida Seminoles rebuilt an economic and social existence outside federal reservation control.[kersey-1972-trade][kersey-1986-depression] A central question in the local history of Highlands County is whether any portion of this post-war Seminole network—trading posts, enumerated camps, federal reservations, day schools, or relief projects—lay within the borders of modern Highlands County or along the southern Lake Wales Ridge surrounding Avon Park.[kersey-1981-census][gonzalez-2025-census]

Systematic studies of archival, commercial, and census records published by historian Harry A. Kersey, Jr. in the Florida Historical Quarterly, corroborated by independent federal ethnohistories and demographic analyses, establish that nineteenth- and twentieth-century Seminole infrastructure was confined to three peripheral regions: the northern Lake Okeechobee prairies, the Atlantic coastal ridge, and the southwestern Big Cypress and Ten Thousand Islands rim.[kersey-1972-trade][kersey-1981-census][gonzalez-2025-census][goss-1995-ethnohistory] Neither Avon Park nor any part of modern Highlands County hosted a documented trading post, federal census enumeration cluster, reservation tract, or Bureau of Indian Affairs institution between 1870 and 1942.[kersey-1972-trade][kersey-1986-depression][kersey-1970-education]

Trading posts and commercial corridors (1870-1930)

Following the Civil War, Seminole families participated heavily in the hide, fur, and plume trade, exchanging alligator skins, otter pelts, and egret plumes for firearms, ammunition, cloth, metal pots, and flour.[kersey-1972-trade] In his study of merchant ledgers and oral histories, Kersey identified the network of white traders operating among the Seminoles between 1870 and 1930.[kersey-1972-trade] This trade was anchored at specific perimeter outposts:

  • Northern and eastern Lake Okeechobee: Operating out of Fort Pierce, Tantie (modern Okeechobee), and Indiantown, traders including the Raulerson firm, Peter P. Cobb, and Joe Bowers served the Muscogee-speaking Cow Creek bands.[kersey-1972-trade]
  • Lower East Coast: From 1893 onward, Frank Stranahan operated a trading post on the New River at modern Fort Lauderdale, drawing Mikasuki families across the Everglades.[kersey-1972-trade]
  • Southwestern Interior and Gulf Coast: In southwestern Florida, William H. Brown operated the “Boat Landing” on the western edge of the Big Cypress Swamp; George Storter maintained a store at Everglade on the Gulf; and merchants in Fort Myers served as the regional wholesale hub.[kersey-1972-trade][goss-1995-ethnohistory]

Highlands County and the Lake Wales Ridge lay entirely outside this commercial circuit.[kersey-1972-trade] When merchants established stores at Avon Park in the late 1880s, their commerce served northern citrus homesteaders and cattlemen, with no recorded Indigenous trade or seasonal supply traffic.[kersey-1972-trade]

Federal census enumerations of 1900 and 1910

The Special Indian Census of 1900, directed by special agent Minnie Moore-Willson and conducted by local enumerators in the field, attempted the first comprehensive federal headcount of Florida Seminoles since 1880.[kersey-1981-census] Enumerators recorded family bands across south Florida, identifying camp locations and kinship ties.[kersey-1981-census][gonzalez-2025-census]

Field enumerators returned a total of 339 Seminoles, though official published census summaries reported slightly adjusted aggregate figures.[kersey-1981-census] Geographic analysis of these census rolls confirms that all enumerated settlements were concentrated outside Highlands County:[kersey-1981-census][gonzalez-2025-census]

  • Northern bands (Cow Creek): Enumerated north and northeast of Lake Okeechobee in modern St. Lucie, Osceola, and Okeechobee counties, timed around the annual Green Corn Dance gathering.[kersey-1981-census]
  • Southern and Western bands (Mikasuki): Enumerated in Dade County (including modern Broward), Lee County (including modern Collier and Hendry), and along Fisheating Creek in modern Glades County.[kersey-1981-census][goss-1995-ethnohistory]

The census rolls record zero Seminole camps, individuals, or households within the boundaries of modern Highlands County or the upper Kissimmee River valley.[kersey-1981-census][gonzalez-2025-census]

Reservation lands, Day schools, and New Deal programs (1920-1942)

Federal administrative oversight expanded during the 1920s and 1930s as drainage projects destroyed traditional hunting grounds.[kersey-1986-depression] Bureau of Indian Affairs investments and relief funding centered on designated reservation parcels:[kersey-1986-depression][kersey-1970-education]

  • Reservation development: The federal government concentrated its efforts on the 360-acre Dania Reservation in Broward County (established by Executive Order in 1911 and built out in 1926), the Big Cypress Reservation in Hendry County, and the Brighton Reservation in Glades County.[kersey-1986-depression]
  • Federal Indian schools: The Bureau of Indian Affairs established day schools exclusively at the reservation centers, operating a day school at Dania from 1927 to 1936 before transferring students to local public schools, and opening day schools at Brighton and Big Cypress in 1938 and 1940.[kersey-1970-education]
  • New Deal relief operations: Civilian Conservation Corps-Indian Division (CCC-ID) camps and Civil Works Administration programs operated in Collier, Hendry, and Glades counties, including cattle breeding projects at Brighton and road-building camps near Miles City.[kersey-1986-depression]

No federal reservation land, Indian day school, or Indian relief program existed in Highlands County.[kersey-1986-depression][kersey-1970-education] While Seminole families traversed waterways south of Lake Istokpoga and traded into Glades and Okeechobee towns, the modern county remained entirely outside the institutional and residential geography of the Seminole community.[kersey-1972-trade][kersey-1981-census][kersey-1986-depression]

References

Where this comes from

Evidence
corroborated — More than one independent source agrees.
Review
unverified — Drafted from sources but not yet checked by a volunteer.
Rights
society

Sources

  1. Harry A. Kersey, Jr., Pelts, Plumes, and Hides: White Traders among the Seminole Indians, 1890-1930 (1972) · secondary
  2. Harry A. Kersey, Jr., The Florida Seminoles and the Census of 1900 (1981) · secondary
  3. Harry A. Kersey, Jr., The Florida Seminoles in the Depression and New Deal, 1933-1942 (1986) · secondary
  4. Harry A. Kersey, Jr., Educating the Seminole Indians of Florida, 1879-1970 (1970) · secondary
  5. Sarah Gonzalez et al., Seminole Adaptations to the Market Economy in the Northern Everglades: An Analysis of the 1900 and 1910 Federal Censuses (2025) · secondary
  6. Clinton M. Goss, The Traditional Cultural Properties of the Big Cypress National Preserve (1995) · official

Something here wrong, or incomplete? The Society would rather know. Tell a volunteer.

Have a question about this record?

← Back to collection

Ask A.P.

Ask the archive

    Try asking:

    0 / 500

    A.P. answers only from the Society's own archive and cites what it used. Questions are not linked to you; search history is stored on your device only (how it works).Ask a volunteer for anything it cannot answer.