The Historical Society of Avon ParkAVON PARK, FL · EST. 1886
Menu
Admin Sign-In

Landowner Co-Relators in the Avon Park Municipal Annexation Quo Warranto, 1932–1934

In 1925, during the Florida land boom, the Florida Legislature enacted Chapter 10320, extending the corporate boundaries of the newly designated City of Avon Park from approximately 1,440 acres (2.25 square miles) to thirty-six complete sections comprising 23,040 acres (36 square miles).[fla-108-641]

When the collapse of property values left the expanded municipality burdened by bond debt and heavy tax assessments, major corporate and individual landowners joined Attorney General Fred H. Davis in an extensive quo warranto proceeding in the Supreme Court of Florida (State ex rel. Davis v. City of Avon Park).[fla-104-389][fla-108-641] The suit sought to oust municipal jurisdiction and tax liability from outlying agricultural, timber, and resort lands that received no municipal benefits.[fla-108-641]

Profile of Named Co-Relators

The reported pleadings in the Florida Supreme Court identify the major agricultural and commercial enterprises operating across Avon Park’s perimeter:

Co-Relator Entity Type and Ownership Landholdings and Economic Operations
Pine Crest Lakes Company & Pine Crest Lakes Country Club Resort & golf development corporation (organized under Col. Royal Page Davidson and A. D. Taylor) Developed the 1926 Pinecrest Hotel on Lake Lotela and the 18-hole golf course designed by Bert Way; resisted municipal taxes on extensive lakeside holdings and club fairways.[fla-104-389][maxwell-1976]
Avon Florida Citrus Corporation Commercial agricultural corporation Large-scale citrus grove investment company holding substantial acreage across the rural annexed sections of Township 33 South, Range 28 East.[fla-104-389]
Avon Manufacturing Company Industrial wood products & crate manufacturer (E. A. DeLaney, superintendent) Operated the major industrial crate mill and sawmill complex along the Atlantic Coast Line railroad spur southwest of Walnut Street, manufacturing citrus shipping crates.[fla-104-389][sanborn-1920][maxwell-1976]
Norton T. Smith Individual property owner & civic leader Prominent early civic figure and booster active in Avon Park development assemblies and commercial improvement projects.[fla-104-389]
John Henry Smith Individual agricultural landowner Significant investor in citrus grove properties and rural acreage within the northern and eastern annexation perimeter.[fla-104-389]
Henry L. Meade Individual landowner Property holder owning outlying unimproved tracts subjected to municipal ad valorem taxation.[fla-104-389]

Judicial Progression and Resolution

The co-relators argued that incorporating 21,600 acres of unplatted citrus groves, pine flatwoods, and scrub into the city was an unconstitutional abuse of legislative power under Section 8 of Article VIII of the Florida Constitution of 1885.[fla-108-641]

After initial rulings on demurrers in 1932 and 1933, the Supreme Court determined that resolving whether specific tracts received municipal benefits required factual findings.[fla-117-565] On 11 December 1934, the Supreme Court entered an order appointing Circuit Judge W. J. Barker of Sebring as Special Commissioner to conduct formal evidentiary hearings in Avon Park to determine which of the thirty-six sections were useful for municipal purposes.[fla-117-565]

Ultimately, the Florida Supreme Court dismissed the original quo warranto proceeding without prejudice because the corelators’ lands were scattered, making a blanket judgment of ouster procedurally improper in that venue.[fla-108-641][fla-178-so-837] The Court established that landowners whose unbenefited rural lands were unconstitutionally taxed by the city had an adequate remedy in equity to enjoin the collection of those municipal taxes, leaving them to pursue relief individually or in the circuit court.[fla-178-so-837]

This litigation represented a united front of Avon Park’s largest private employers—resort developers, crate mill operators, and citrus syndicates—seeking relief from boom-era municipal overexpansion, which they achieved through equity injunctions rather than a single statewide writ.[fla-104-389][fla-108-641]

References

Where this comes from

Evidence
corroborated — More than one independent source agrees.
Review
unverified — Drafted from sources but not yet checked by a volunteer.
Rights
society

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Florida, State ex rel. Davis v. City of Avon Park, 104 Fla. 389, 139 So. 899 (2 March 1932) (1932)
  2. Supreme Court of Florida (Whitfield, J.), State ex rel. Attorney General v. City of Avon Park, 108 Fla. 641, 149 So. 409 (10 March 1933, on re-argument 2 June 1933) (1933)
  3. Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc (Brown, J.), State ex rel. Davis v. City of Avon Park, 117 Fla. 565, 158 So. 159 (11 December 1934) (1934)
  4. Supreme Court of Florida, City of Sarasota v. Skillin, 130 Fla. 724, 178 So. 837 (1937) (1937)
  5. Sanborn Map Company, Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Avon Park, Highlands County, Florida, November 1920, sheet 4 (1920)
  6. Leoma Bradshaw Maxwell, The First Hundred Years of Avon Park, Florida (Held at the Avon Park Historical Society Depot Museum, Avon Park, Florida) (1976) · book

Something here wrong, or incomplete? The Society would rather know. Tell a volunteer.

Have a question about this record?

← Back to collection

Ask A.P.

Ask the archive

    Try asking:

    0 / 500

    A.P. answers only from the Society's own archive and cites what it used. Questions are not linked to you; search history is stored on your device only (how it works).Ask a volunteer for anything it cannot answer.